Isaf Nasya And Others v. Emperor

Isaf Nasya And Others v. Emperor

(High Court Of Judicature At Calcutta)

CALCUTTA HIGH COURT | 08-09-1926

Duval, J.In this matter a complaint was lodged before the District Magistrate of Rungpore on the 16th February 1926, against certain people of charges u/s 366, I.P.C., and other sections. The complainant was examined on oath, as provided for in Section 200, Criminal P.C., and the Magistrate then passed an order sending the case to the police for inquiry, but adding:

The police will see if there is any evidence for the submission of a charge-sheet, and after that they will send it to the Magistrate concerned.

2. As a matter of fact it appears that the alleged place of occurrence was within Nilphamari, a sub-division of the Bung-pore District. An inquiry was made by the police, and on the 3rd May, a charge-sheet was submitted to the Sub-divisional Officer of Nilphamari, who thereupon issued a warrant for the arrest of certain accused persons. Certain of the accused subsequently surrendered, and then an application was made to the Sessions Judge to refer the matter to this Court for quashing of the whole proceedings. The Sessions Judge, however, refused to refer the matter to this Court, and this rule was then obtained from this Court why the proceedings should not be quashed on the grounds (1) that the procedure adopted by the District Magistrate is wrong, inasmuch as he acted under Chap. 16, Cri P.O., and then proceeded under Chap. 14, Cri P.C., (2) that, after having taken cognizance of the case u/s 190, Clause (a), and proceeded u/s 200, the learned Magistrate had no power to act u/s 156(3); (3) that his action in directing the police to submit a charge-sheet is illegal and without jurisdiction; (4) that the Sub-divisional Magistrate of Nilphamari has no jurisdiction, unless the case is transferred to him according to the provisions of law.

3. Now the facts seem to be clear; the Magistrate took cognizance of a complaint u/s 200, Criminal P.C., and it would appear that he referred the case to the police for inquiry under his power to to so u/s 202, Criminal P.C., but in giving that order he did not observe that it was for him to pass the necessary order on the police report either u/s 203 or Section 204. His order, therefore, directing the police, if they found the case to be established, to submit charge-sheet to the Magistrate concerned (in this case the Sub-divisional Officer of Nilphamari) appears to us to have been without jurisdiction. We do not think that Section 156(3) can have any application to the case before us. The Magistrate had certainly taken cognizance of the case u/s 200, and it appears to us that this section only empowers the Magistrate to order a police inquiry in a case when the Magistrate does not himself issue process at once. It seems, therefore, that the whole of the proceedings of the Sub-divisional Officer, Nilphamari, accepting the charge-sheet and proceeding with the case, without any order by the District Magistrate u/s 204, Criminal P.C., or any order of transfer of the case to him u/s 192 are without jurisdiction and must be set aside. We, accordingly, set these orders aside, and send the proceeding back to the District Magistrate of Rangpore who will now u/s 203 or Section 204 pass the necessary orders on the police inquiry which has taken place; and if he so thinks he may issue processes and transfer the case to the Sub-divisional Officer for trial or inquiry.

4. The rule is made absolute to the extent only that the later orders are set aside. The order of the District Magistrate taking cognizance will remain, and he will now pass orders in the manner directed above.

Chotzner, J.

5. I agree.

Advocate List
Bench
  • HON'BLE JUSTICE Duval, J
  • HON'BLE JUSTICE Chotzner, J
Eq Citations
  • (1927) ILR 54 CAL 303
  • 102 IND. CAS. 545
  • AIR 1928 CAL 24
  • LQ/CalHC/1926/278
Head Note

Criminal Procedure Code, 1898 — Ss. 190, 200, 202 and 204 — Magistrate taking cognizance of complaint u/s 200 Crl. P.C. and referring case to police for inquiry u/s 202 Crl. P.C. — Order directing police to submit charge-sheet to Magistrate concerned, if they found case to be established, held, without jurisdiction — Proceedings of Sub-divisional Magistrate accepting charge-sheet and proceeding with case, without any order by District Magistrate u/s 204 Crl. P.C. or any order of transfer of case to him u/s 192 Crl. P.C., held, without jurisdiction — Ss. 156(3), 190 and 202 Crl. P.C.