Open iDraf
Hon'ble Chief Justice, High Court M. P. Jabalpur v. Mohan Kumar

Hon'ble Chief Justice, High Court M. P. Jabalpur
v.
Mohan Kumar

(Supreme Court Of India)

No | 23-08-1993


Pandian, S.R. (J)

1.We are in a state of extreme pain on receipt of a distress signal sent by the learned Chief Justice of Madhya Pradesh by his letter dated August 6, 1993 informing this Court that the judicial work in the State of Madhya Pradesh in all the three Benches and the judicial administration at the State level have virtually come to a grinding halt for the reasons mentioned in the letter and requesting this Court to take notice of the present unpleasant and unsavoury situation and transfer the public interest litigation initially registered as N.P. No. 1532 of 1993 at Indore and subsequently transferred to the main seat of the High Court at Jabalpur and re-registered as N.P. No. 3077 of 1993 by exercising the powers under Article 139-A(2) of the Constitution.

2.Though we are quite aware of the legal position that this Court is not having any supervisory control over the administration of a High Court, yet in order to keep the machinery of the institution on move and also in order to avoid any further complications, we are constrained to make the following order:

3.Under this circumstance the learned Chief Justice of Madhya Pradesh shall call for a Full Court meeting of all the Honble Judges of all the three Benches, namely, Gwalior, Jabalpur and Indore on August 28, 1993 at 3.00 p.m. in the court premises at Jabalpur. If the learned Chief Justice, for any reason, is unable to attend the meeting, the said meeting shall be presided over by the seniormost puisne judge present.

4.In the said meeting an Administrative Committee consisting of seven Judges of all the Benches of the High Court including the learned Chief Justice shall be constituted.

5.The Committee shall comprise of two Judges from each of the Benches of the High Court and shall be presided over by the learned Chief Justice. This Committee shall be constituted/elected/selected by the Full Court.

6.The said Committee shall function up to December 31, 1993 looking after the transfer of Subordinate Judges and shall be responsible for the administration including the transfers of the subordinate judiciary. This Committee shall be in supersession of the earlier Administrative Committee and the Transfer Committee.

7.We direct a notice be issued to the Registrar of the High Court of Jabalpur directing him to submit a report on or before September 2, 1993 intimating the results of the proceedings of the meeting and the action taken thereon.

8.At this stage Mr S.K. Agnihotri accepts notice on behalf of the Registrar as well as of the learned Chief Justice of Madhya Pradesh. Mr S.A. Gambhir appearing with Mr A. Mathur accepts notice for Mr Mohan Kumar, respondent herein.

9. The Registry is directed to send this order to the learned Chief Justice and to the Registrar of the High Court by telex/fax and also by the normal method.

10. Meanwhile, there will be a stay of the proceedings in the said M.P. No. 3077 of 1993 pending in the High Court of Jabalpur. The transfer orders of the Subordinate Judges pursuant to the order dated July 17, 1993 are suspended. 11. List the matter on September 2, 1993 before the same Bench. If the same Bench is not sitting on that day, list the matter in the chambers at 1.30 p.m. 12. Copy of the order may be given today itself.

Advocates List

For

For Petitioner
  • Shekhar Naphade
  • Mahesh Agrawal
  • Tarun Dua
For Respondent
  • S. Vani
  • B. Sunita Rao
  • Sushil Kumar Pathak

Bench List

HON'BLE JUSTICE S. R. PANDIAN

HON'BLE JUSTICE KULDIP SINGH

Eq Citation

1993 (4) SCALE 656

(1994) SUPPL. 2 SCC 602

LQ/SC/1993/642

HeadNote

Constitution of India — Arts. 215 and 229 — PIL filed in High Court — Transfer of — Judicial work in State of M.P. in all three Benches and judicial administration at State level having virtually come to a grinding halt — Held, though Supreme Court is not having any supervisory control over administration of High Court, yet in order to keep machinery of institution on move and also in order to avoid any further complications, Full Court meeting of all Judges of all three Benches of High Court to be called by Chief Justice of M.P. and Administrative Committee consisting of seven Judges of all Benches of High Court including Chief Justice to be constituted by Full Court — Stay of proceedings in PIL pending in High Court and transfer orders of Subordinate Judges pursuant to order dt. 17-7-1993 suspended — Constitution of India — Arts. 139-A and 32 — Constitution of India — Arts. 139-A and 32 — Constitution of India — Arts. 139-A and 32