Bishan Chand
v.
Vth Additional District Judge, Bulandshahr (uttar Pradesh) And Another
(Supreme Court Of India)
Civil Appeal No. 2199 of 1980 and Special Leave Petition (Civil) No. 1871 of 1980 | 22-09-1980
1. Special leave to appeal granted.
2. On hearing counsel on either side we are satisfied that in. the circumstances of the case the matter requires to be remanded. In the ejectment suit by the landlord the Vth Addl. District Judge, Bullandshahr, who disposed of the appeal, has unfortunately recorded a finding on the question of comparative hardship in a peculiar way. He held that hardship to both the landlord and the tenant would be the same. If that be the finding, in the absence of any additional circumstance indicating that preference could be shown to the landlord the ejectment order in his favour could not be made. Apart from this, it does appear that Rule 16(2) of U.P. Urban Buildings (Regulation of Letting, Rent and Eviction) Rules, 1972 has not been considered at all by the appellate court. Such an order has been confirmed by the High Court. We, therefore, set aside the High Courts order and send the case back to the District Judge for disposal of the appeal in accordance with law with a direction to consider the question of comparative hardship in the light of the aforesaid Rule 16(2) While considering this question it will be open to the appellate court to take into consideration the facts relating to the earlier agreement, the offer of the appellant before us to give back his own shop to the respondent and the equities arising in the case. Opportunity is given to the parties to lead additional evidence in the form of affidavits before the appellate Court. The matter is accordingly remanded. There will be no order as to costs of the appeal.
Advocates List
NONE
For Petitioner
- Shekhar Naphade
- Mahesh Agrawal
- Tarun Dua
For Respondent
- S. Vani
- B. Sunita Rao
- Sushil Kumar Pathak
Bench List
HON'BLE JUSTICE V. D. TULZAPURKAR
HON'BLE JUSTICE R. S. SARKARIA
Eq Citation
1982 ALJ 882
AIR 1982 SC 1230
1982 (2) RCR (RENT) 272
(1982) 1 SCC 626
LQ/SC/1980/403
HeadNote
Deleting Note..
Are you sure you want to move this note to trash?
