Baimanekbai v. Manekji Kavas Ji And Others

Baimanekbai v. Manekji Kavas Ji And Others

(High Court Of Judicature At Bombay)

| 08-12-1880

1. Inasmuch as we are of opinion that Article 178 of Schedule II of Act XV of 1877 is limited to applications made under the Code of Civil Procedure, we hold that applications for probate, or letters or certificates of administration, do not fall within that article. An examination of all the other articles in the second schedule relating to "applications," that is to say, of the third division of that schedule, shows that the applications therein contemplated are such as are made under the Civil Procedure Code. Hence it is natural to conclude that the applications referred to in Article 178 are applications ejusdem generis, i.e. applications under the Code of Civil Procedure. The preamble of the Act moreover, purports to deal with "certain applications" only, and not with all applications. We reverse the order of the Acting District Judge of the 16th July, 1880, and direct the present District Judge to proceed to hear and dispose of the cases on its merits. Costs of this appeal and of the application should abide the result of the hearing on the merits.

Advocate List
Bench
  • HONBLE JUSTICE MICHAEL ROBERTS WESTROPP
  • KT. C.J.
  • HONBLE JUSTICE MAXWELL MELVILL
  • J.
Eq Citations
  • ILR 1883 7 BOM 213
  • LQ/BomHC/1880/2
Head Note

Limitation Act (XV of 1877)—Article 178, Schedule II—Applicability to applications for probate, letters of administration, or certificate of administration. —Article 178 of Schedule II of Act XV of 1877 held applies only to applications made under the Civil Procedure Code. —Applications for probate, or letters or certificates of administration, held, did not fall within Article 178.