Q. What are the equivalent citations for Ambler vs Sami Ahmed ?

The equivalence citation are(1910) ILR 37 CAL 331 ; LQ/CalHC/1910/44 ;

Ambler Vs. Sami Ahmed On 25 January, 1910

Q: Q. What was the bench assigned for the case Ambler vs Sami Ahmed?

HONBLE MR. JUSTICE STEPHEN, HONBLE MR. JUSTICE CARNDUFF

Ambler
v.
Sami Ahmed

(High Court Of Judicature At Calcutta)

No. | 25-01-1910

[1] In this case the land was attached by the Magistrate under Section 146, Criminal Procedure Code. Subsequently the petitioner obtained an order in his favour from the hands of the survey authorities under Section 41 of the Bengal Survey Act. He now applies to have the attachment released in his favour and he is entitled to have it so released because, the order of the Collector under the Act is a determination by a competent Court of the rights of the person entitled to the land. It is also a determination of the rights of the parties to the original dispute, since the two parties in the original dispute were also both before the Survey Court. An order has also been made under the Bengal Tenancy Act, the effect of which we need not notice, as the order under the Survey Act has the force of an order of any Civil Court.

[2] The Rule, therefore, is made absolute the order in question is set aside and the attachment must be released in favour of the petitioner.

Advocates List

For The Appearing Parties ----.

Bench List

HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE STEPHEN

HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE CARNDUFF

Eq Citation

(1910) ILR 37 CAL 331

LQ/CalHC/1910/44

HeadNote

Criminal Procedure Code, 1973 – S. 146 r/w S. 451 – Attachment of land by Magistrate under S. 146, CrPC – Validity of – Held, order of Collector under Bengal Survey Act is a determination by a competent Court of the rights of the person entitled to the land – It is also a determination of the rights of the parties to the original dispute, since the two parties in the original dispute were also both before the Survey Court — Attachment of land — Bengal Survey Act, 1879, S. 41